Low home appraisals: Understanding the next steps

by Bill and Aby Brooks, REALTORS® 03/02/2025

The process of purchasing a home can be tedious, as there are many legalities and service providers you’ll work with to accomplish buying a property. One of these vital steps is the appraisal process, in which mortgage lenders send over a professional appraiser to examine a property.

This is done to make sure its value is equivalent to the loan amount being requested. If you get a low appraisal offer, it’s valuable to know your options to proceed forward in the most orderly way possible. 


What happens if an appraisal comes back lower than the offer price?

Sometimes the appraised value of a home will come back lower than the requested loan amount due to a number of factors. If the home fails to meet certain guidelines, your lender may decide to offer you less funding than originally requested or may not agree to the loan at all. 

However, there are options in favor of the buyer in the case a home appraisal comes in lower than expected. 


How do you negotiate with a seller after a low appraisal?

In the case of a low appraisal, it’s essential to do research to get a better understanding of why the report came back lower than the purchase price. Research the local real estate market because in some cases, if the home has been on the market for a while, the listing price may be outdated. 

If the low appraisal was justified, you can negotiate with the seller to help pay for needed repairs or ask if they can meet you in the middle with their listing price. 


Can buyers back out if the appraisal is low?

If there is an appraisal contingency in the purchase agreement, a buyer can back out of a home purchase if the appraisal comes back too low. This is why it’s vital to examine and pay close attention to detail with the help of your real estate agent to all items in the purchase contract. 

A low home appraisal isn’t the end of your home buying process, it’s simply an obstacle that can be overcome with research and planning. 


About the Author
Author

Bill and Aby Brooks, REALTORS®

Aby’s understanding of excellent customer service stems from her extensive professional background. Prior to earning her real estate license in 2005, along with her college degree that focuses on business and engineering, Aby was the head of purchasing, inventory and quality assurance for an OEM medical and aerospace manufacturing company. Known by her clients and fellow realtors for her tenacity, honesty, integrity, and attention to detail, as a full-time realtor, she is also appreciated for her quick response to her client’s needs. Aby has been an avid horse rider and owner since the age of eight, with her husband Billas a local firefighter/EMT they are very active within the community. Bill served as a US Army Airborne Ranger in 75th Ranger Regiment, he is a combat-wounded veteran who was awarded a Purple Heart. Bill's background as facility Manager for an International metals company and as a firefighter/EMT gives him the experience, attention to detail and the desire to go above and beyond to serve his customers. The Brooks' serve on the board of a local non-profit (501c3) that gives back to the veterans, first responders and their families. The Brooks family resides on their small ranch in Manatee County. Aby& Bill excel in all types of real estate and their passion is helping people. “We genuinely like people, growing up in Sarasota and Manatee counties and now raising our own family here, it is an absolute pleasure to share our growing area with newcomers and reminisce with longtime residents. Our area has so much to offer and it is our business to help folks buy and sell their own piece of paradise.”